PDA

View Full Version : Gotham Underground



Mac_Apple
03-10-2016, 06:59 PM
Crisis 3 really needed a better way to trade VP. This card is just some brainstorming I'm doing... opinions?

http://i66.tinypic.com/2py29za.jpg

Examples:

"I'll offer my Vibe for your Grid" - Good
"I'll offer 4 VPs for that Royal Flush Gang" - Good
"I'll offer my Ultra Strength for 6 VPs" - Good
"I'll offer Superwoman and 3 VPs for your Ultraman" - Good
"I'll offer 0 VPs to take that Punch off of your hands" - Wrong
"I'll offer my Vibe, Grid, Element Woman, and Steel for your Constructs of Fear" - Wrong

Reasoning- Offering multiple cards would get obnoxious very quickly. A player could also offer their entire deck for 1 card and that would break the game.

BenJazz
03-10-2016, 09:03 PM
I like the concept but I would avoid negotiation as that slows the game down too much. I would recommend "Once during each of your turns, you may choose another player. Move X VP from your character to that players character. That player must discard cards from their hand into your discard pile until they have discarded X VP or have no cards in hand." I think this also let's the card work in non-Crisis play without becoming too broken. The player with the location has to take the risk of whether you have cards that are worth it in your hand and potentially gain starters/weaknesses (RISK!).