Search:

Type: Posts; User: Cacheelma

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    When you bring up balance issues and how changes...

    When you bring up balance issues and how changes to rules (that are similar to MTG) would affect other parts of the game, it all comes down to...:

    Why made them similar in the first place, though?...
  2. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    The threshold system is an improvement of MTG's...

    The threshold system is an improvement of MTG's land/mana system in that you won't get "color-screw" that easily in Hex. But that's all there is to it. Without the threshold system in Hex, you won't...
  3. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Sigh.. I am daring you to find A CARD that has...

    Sigh..

    I am daring you to find A CARD that has both abilities. Two abilities. On one card. The same way Atrophy/Instill Infection do.

    My point is if it weren't an act of copying, I fail to see...
  4. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    I guess you misunderstood me. Where's the...

    I guess you misunderstood me.

    Where's the -1/-1 counter giving ability in pot of greed and bill?
  5. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    As far as I know, MTG doesn't look at balance...

    As far as I know, MTG doesn't look at balance beyond "standard" these days. They set a powerlevel for cards and make sure cards don't exceed said powerlevel. Instill Infection is the way it is...
  6. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Removal on a card is normal. But can't you see...

    Removal on a card is normal. But can't you see they're EXACTLY the same? I dare you to find a card from other TCG that has the exact same TWO abilities on a card like this pair.
  7. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Does LoL trademark/patent/whatever anything to...

    Does LoL trademark/patent/whatever anything to have the right to sue any other similar games, though? And they don't sue doesn't mean they can't. WotC decided to sue doesn't make them "wrong".
  8. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Let's put everything else aside guys and look at...

    Let's put everything else aside guys and look at this together for one moment and ponder my questions:

    http://imgur.com/a/nHV7g

    Just the first pair of cards alone (Atrophy vs. Instill...
  9. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Right? This shouldn't have happened to begin...

    Right? This shouldn't have happened to begin with. Borrow something is fine. Having something similar is ok. Making the whole thing play out nearly the same way down to the small details is just......
  10. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    These improvements are all well and good. The...

    These improvements are all well and good. The real question though is why didn't they use any of these in the first place? Maybe because it didn't work well enough?

    Looking from a different...
  11. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    My point is it's not up to any of us here to...

    My point is it's not up to any of us here to decide. Again, we are more or less on the same side here. There's no point attacking each other.
  12. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Yeah yeah even I wish it's totally up to you to...

    Yeah yeah even I wish it's totally up to you to decide that...
  13. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    That depends on how selfish you are imo. When...

    That depends on how selfish you are imo.

    When I backed this game. I was too busy to look at the gameplay video. I backed Hex purely because the PvE content was promising enough. In other words,...
  14. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    I am a king tier backer. But due to personal...

    I am a king tier backer. But due to personal reasons I don't have much time to play, leave alone reading this forum. I had been impatiently waiting for PvE content until I heard about the legal...
  15. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Don't even get me to start on that. To be honest....

    Don't even get me to start on that. To be honest. My thought process when I "Backed" this project was a little different from yours. But we are more or less in the same boat here (being surprised...
  16. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    That could be true. But nobody knows other than...

    That could be true. But nobody knows other than the party involved. The outcome is what we are seeing, though. I have no legal knowledge but I've heard about that Ryan Seacrest iPhone-Keyboard...
  17. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    All of which WotC took years to research and...

    All of which WotC took years to research and balance and came up with, hence imo one of the reasons they're sueing us. We are going back to the "if it ain't broke..." arguement here. Other TCGs came...
  18. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    That depends on what was copyrighted by Id...

    That depends on what was copyrighted by Id Software, no? There are other things in this case too not just copyrights.
  19. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    Again, my point is, they don't have to be so...

    Again, my point is, they don't have to be so similar though. Other TCGs are not this similar to MtG. None of them are THIS similar. And that's, in my opinion, one of the reasons why Hex got sued and...
  20. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    My point is, this is one of the small details...

    My point is, this is one of the small details that Hex is similar to MtG when it doesn't have to be so. Why name AND have the cost of a card the same as MtG when you don't need to? Same goes for why...
  21. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    The two Murder cards are actually functioning a...

    The two Murder cards are actually functioning a bit differently: MtG's Murder can destroy ANY creature. Hex's Murder can only destroy non-artifact creature (oops, I mean, Troop).

    A card from MtG...
  22. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    The thing is though, HEX cards right now are also...

    The thing is though, HEX cards right now are also two-sided (right? or am I too stupid to flip them to the double-back side?).

    I don't know about the law, but had the PvE side of Hex come out...
  23. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    You have to look at the big picture though, not...

    You have to look at the big picture though, not just some small details. But at the same time you can't ignore these small details either.

    I mean, a small and trivial things like "having 5...
  24. Replies
    1,295
    Views
    191,580

    You can change the colors around. You can change...

    You can change the colors around. You can change the name of the colors around. One thing that they mentioned in the complaint that you can't deny though is the fact that there are "5" distinct...
Results 1 to 24 of 24