Results 1 to 3 of 3
  1. #1

    Portal Board Game query re: "majority"?

    P.12 of the rulebook reads: "The player with the majority of Test Subjects in the 'activated' Test Chamber earns the rewards displayed in that panel. No players are rewarded if there are no Test Subjects in the 'activated' Chamber, or if there is a tie for majority."

    The underlining for "majority" is in the text. Some clarification requested:

    The term "the majority of Test Subjects" indicates that over half of the Test Subjects in the Chamber need to belong to one player. This means there are cases where no-one will have "the majority of Test Subjects"; for example: [Three players have Test Subjects in the chamber. The first has three, the second has two and the third has one. None of the players has the majority of Test Subjects].

    There being a "tie for majority" would occur in one case, where two different players had an equal number of Test Subjects in the Chamber, with no third or fourth player having any Test Subjects present at the same time. There is no mention in the rulebook of what should happen if there is neither a majority, not a tie for majority, though the natural implication would be that the same result should apply as when there is a tie for majority, i.e. no reward.

    Is this implication correct?

    OR: Does the absence of any mention of what to do this case imply an alternative explanation; that what is in fact intended by the rules by "the majority of Test Subjects" is rather "the highest number of Test Subjects", and not a literal reading of the text? In which case in the above example the reward would be given to the first player, who has three Test Subjects.

    Some disagreement about this among my gaming buddies.

  2. #2
    Cryptozoic Employee Matt_Hyra's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Irvine, CA
    Posts
    2,319
    It should have been plurality, but most people aren’t familiar with that word.
    You just need to have more than any other player.
    Original Designer
    DC Deck-Building Game

  3. #3
    Quote Originally Posted by AaronLandon11 View Post
    P.12 of the rulebook reads: "The player with the majority of Test Subjects in the 'activated' Test Chamber earns the rewards displayed in that panel. No players are rewarded if there are no Test Subjects in the 'activated' Chamber, or if there is a tie for majority."

    The underlining for "majority" is in the text. Some clarification requested:

    The term "the majority of Test Subjects" indicates that over half of the Test Subjects in the Chamber need to belong to one player. This means there are cases where no-one will have "the majority of Test Subjects"; for example: [Three players have Test Subjects in the chamber. The first has three, the second has two and the third has one. None of the players has the majority of Test Subjects].

    There being a "tie for majority" would occur in one case, where two different players had an equal number of Test Subjects in the Chamber, with no third or fourth player having any Test Subjects present at the same time. There is no mention in the rulebook of what should happen if there is neither a majority, not a tie for majority, though the natural implication would be that the same result should apply as when there is a tie for majority, i.e. no reward.

    Is this implication correct?

    OR: Does the absence of any mention of what to do this case imply an alternative explanation; that what is in fact intended by the rules by "the majority of Test Subjects" is rather "the highest number of Test Subjects", and not a literal reading of the text? In which case in the above example the omegle xender reward would be given to the first player, who has three Test Subjects.

    Some disagreement about this among my gaming buddies.
    thank you my issue has been solved

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •